Comments on: SocProf Supports William I. Robinson | The Global Sociology Blog http://www.tmttlt.com/2009/04/24/socprof-supports-william-i-robinson-the-global-sociology-blog/ All those topics that i wish i had time to pursue more earnestly. Fri, 05 Jun 2009 16:40:54 -0700 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.8.4 hourly 1 By: jason http://www.tmttlt.com/2009/04/24/socprof-supports-william-i-robinson-the-global-sociology-blog/comment-page-1/#comment-458 jason Sun, 26 Apr 2009 12:45:00 +0000 http://www.tmttlt.com/archives/2009/04/24/6229/#comment-458 I miss the point. Having the right to academic freedom is great. But the right of people to get pissed off at that things you say is also great. Academic freedom is NOT immunity from anger or outrage, misguided or not. I have only online reports, but if the guy is so thick to think that these are the only two events he could juxtapose, then he's a weak academic, IMHO. I feel I can take issue with the actions of the israeli state while supporting the jewish people's around the world, as one reference says was his position. But to say there is nothing questionable in the judgement regarding talking about German actions in Poland vs Israeli actions in Gaza that would upset people is really rather thick on is part. And to be shocked that people outside of academe would call for your head (note that there is no requirement that they be well versed in and respect notions of academic freedom) makes me question him having the social skills required for a job that interacts with the public. Sure, I support his academic freedom, but what a twitt. I miss the point. Having the right to academic freedom is great. But the right of people to get pissed off at that things you say is also great. Academic freedom is NOT immunity from anger or outrage, misguided or not. I have only online reports, but if the guy is so thick to think that these are the only two events he could juxtapose, then he’s a weak academic, IMHO. I feel I can take issue with the actions of the israeli state while supporting the jewish people’s around the world, as one reference says was his position. But to say there is nothing questionable in the judgement regarding talking about German actions in Poland vs Israeli actions in Gaza that would upset people is really rather thick on is part. And to be shocked that people outside of academe would call for your head (note that there is no requirement that they be well versed in and respect notions of academic freedom) makes me question him having the social skills required for a job that interacts with the public.

Sure, I support his academic freedom, but what a twitt.

]]>